The word Jägermeister might conjure up the chaos of a college frat party, but here’s the thing: this German liqueur is working on its reputation. Jagermeister is a legit herbal digestif liqueur that’s ready for a comeback. Honestly, it’s got more in common with an Italian amaro than a crappy party drink. It’s great as a shot, but even more interesting mixed into cocktails like the Negroni or Old Fashioned.